Give Me Transmigration or Give Me Death!
Plant
a watermelon
On the bottom o’ my grave
And let the juice –
Slurp! Slurp! run through.
Plant a watermelon
On the bottom o’ my grave
That’s all I ask of you.
Now Mom makes
chicken
And she makes it mighty fine,
But nothin’ can compare
With the watermelon vine.
So plant a watermelon
On the bottom o’ my grave
And let the juice –
Slurp! Slurp! run through.
I recently had a conversation
with UC Berkeley biologist Steven A. Garan about his systems approach to
studying life extension, or what was once more modestly termed longevity, and
about his little business on the side –
cryopreservation of humans. I was polite. On the inside I may have been howling with
laughter when I asked, did he expect any serious competition for business from
the Whole Brain Emulation folks? But I posed the question with a straight face.
Before meeting with Professor Garan, my most recent update on cryogenic
suspension – that is, on preserving dead humans at sub-zero temperatures, would have made excellent material
for a stand-up comedian. For not only was benighted Homo sapiens sapiens spending
megabucks in the quixotic hope that science would soon figure out how to “wake
people up,” people who couldn’t afford the whole gruesome package were still spending megabucks at a discounted
rate for the privilege of having their heads kept indefinitely on ice, giving
new meaning to the term Deadheads.
Where was Mark Twain when you
really needed him?
So you thought selling
aluminum siding was the worst job in the world, did you? Try being head (so
to speak) of the sales team whose job it is to close on the deal with the guy
who can only afford to get his head frozen.
You want to know the answer
to my question? The answer was that the technology for bringing the cryonically-preserved
back to life is a mere ten years away, whereas the technology for up– (or is it down– ?) loading people’s brains
lies a good fifty years hence. So no competition. No competition at all. The
cryonic preservers are earliest to market – earlier than the WBE folks by
forty-odd years.
I never wanted to have my brain
uploaded anyway. What would be the point? I’m not Einstein. Nor am I Steven
Hawking. I have a good, unexceptional brain. Most humans do have good brains – thanks to evolution we have good BIG brains
inside our craniums, and they keep on growing and developing postpartum for
something like twenty-five years. And these good BIG brains are supplied to our
species free of charge, with every new generation.
How about waking up as-is
though, body and all, after, say, an interval of about fifty years? Let me say
this about that. RIP is there for a reason. Do we
say, “Rest in jollity”? Do we say, “Rest in hilarity”? or “Rest in audacity”?
Do we say, “Rest in party-mode”? No. No we do not. Someone dies, we don’t say:
“Party on.” We say: “Rest in Peace.”
What happens in Vegas stays in Vegas. And what happens with the dead
stays with the dead. Not to put too fine
a point on it, the beneficence of phrases like “Stay lucky” pales in comparison
to the good wishes we may bestow in future when we tell friends and colleagues
to “Stay dead.”
Oh you thought RIP was an
acronym for Rip Van Winkle did you? Well, why not? Van Winkle’s tale might
serve as a weak analogy for the fifty-year resurrection.
Rip had some issues, his
creator tells us. Fortunately for Rip, he fell asleep and woke up in a
backwater: in a rustic society where people didn’t bathe all that much to begin
with. So what if he slept in his clothes, perspired in his clothes, etc. in his
clothes? Everybody smelled bad in those days. So what if he hadn’t flossed or finger-combed
his beard? Neither had the rest of the ornery recluses and neurotic misanthropes who
lived thereabouts. The colonial American backwoods was full of benign eccentrics
and sly curmudgeons. If he had any social problems on waking, therefore, such problems
were related to disorientation, not hygiene.
Now the example of Rip was
just an analogy, and a weak one at that. So what would it actually be like to
die unto cryonic preservation and wake unto life fifty years hence? That is
assuming some controlled intervention that has not disrupted the organism. It
would perforce be an intervention less passionate than the kiss
that brought Sleeping Beauty around, less romantic and more targeted to
arouse consciousness itself than merely to bring the endocrine system back
online.
What state indeed would your
awakening resemble? Would you experience new life as enlightenment, as being
suffused with tranquil illumination, amidst a shaking off of the ether whilst a
kindly medic warmly held your chilly hand?
I
took her hand in mine, and we went out of the ruined place; and
as the morning
mists had risen long ago when I left the forge, so, the evening mists were
rising now, and in all the broad expanse of tranquil light they showed to me, I
saw the shadow
of no parting from her.
–– Great Expectations
Or perhaps not so much
resurrection as rebirth – the experience
of rebirth where birth had been but a cacophony:
The baby assailed by eyes, ears, nose, skin and entrails all at once, feels it as one great blooming, buzzing confusion. . .
– Principles of Psychology
So said William James of the
baby’s experience of the world following birth.
Enlightenment? Cacophony? I
think not. For you would not be regaining consciousness among the Angels.
Neither Seraphim nor Cherubim would attend you; rather they would send you back from whence
you came. Look Homeward, Angel, if angel you may be; look earthward, not
with a mind that’s tabula rasa, nor
like a convict with a clean slate; or even like a kid with an Etch-a-Sketch. You
bring the rudiments at least of the mind you left with; if there is any
backsliding, it should take one no further backwards in time than very
adolescence.
Ever had a surprise party?
That’s what it would feel like. You haven’t brushed your teeth or had a bath.
You weren’t expecting this party, no, and you’ve had no time to find a suitable
outfit. You’re not at your best, not having a good day, and to be honest, you
don’t just not look good, you look like shit. Because the thing is, you’ve been
dead. Not just kind of dead or out-of-body dead, or in a coma dead, but really,
really dead. Dead as a doornail kind of thing. Dead as a doornail on ice, sure,
but still and all, long-time dead. That doornail’s been on ice for fifty years,
see. And who really knows how much suspension takes place in fifty years, how
much devolution, dementia, decay? And there they all are, those party-goers of
the future, jazzed because you’re awake, because they woke you. And they’re screaming,
“Happy birthday!” and “Party on!” And
you look like shit and you feel like Frankenstein’s monster. You never meant
for it to happen this way. It’s the worst, the very
worst surprise party ever.
Remember the time your friend
was in a coma? That was in another life. Lying in bed for over a week,
not using his muscles, he developed foot-flop, thought he might never get back
his muscle tone; took half a year with PT to recover.
And they’ve de-iced you, sure
enough. It’s your début. What are those hellishly bright lights scathing your
tender eyeballs? You’re here, what’s left of you. What hasn’t atrophied. Or
been infected. Or inflamed. But you haven’t exactly been getting regular
exercise, a healthy diet, and fresh air.
You thought you’d be burning
with curiosity to see what life was like in the future, but you’re sodden with
something that feels like a hangover, jetlag, and “I overslept by forty years” all rolled into
one: you’re a morning lark at midnight, a night owl at high noon.
So this is 2075? But no.
There was a war. They didn’t have the resources, the technology to wake you in
2075. Your contract, you say? They howl with laughter. May have been binding in
the old US of A. But this is 3030, you're in Pan-Solaria. . .
OK. I got carried away. But I
do so love Sci-fi. And you get the point.
Humans have searched for
immortality probably since they understood that they die. They have always
overstepped. Then they created warnings, stories, myths. Calendars and clocks.
The Phoenix. Shangri-la. Aurora and Tithonus.
For those who were not fools,
there was transmigration, meditation, reincarnation. For the fools there was
the Fountain of Youth, immortal fame, and cryonic preservation.
For the wise, there was
knowledge never contained in the words by which they remembered it.
And sware by him that liveth for ever and ever, who created heaven,
and the things that therein are, and the sea, and the things
which are therein, that there should be time no longer.
–– Revelation
It takes a while to value time
I'll take a break
Arrive too late
If I fall behind it is you I'll find
In a lovely house
In a lovely town
–– Good Occasions
The moment you stop thought, Time too stops dead.
–– Shakespeare
1 comment:
+linda colman Powerful insights on enlightenment and reincarnation of the mind, your descriptions euphoric and transcendental. I love this passage, as I can relate to the chaos:
"Or perhaps not so much resurrection as rebirth – the experience of rebirth where birth had been but a cacophony:
The baby assailed by eyes, ears, nose, skin and entrails all at once, feels it as one great blooming, buzzing confusion. . .
– Principles of Psychology"
Cognitive dissonance is another term for the disorientation of new ideas, learning, and thinking, and the experience can be traumatic, confusing. You question old and traditional ways of thinking about beliefs you have clung to for a very long time. However, growth emerges from the chaos, an evolution in thinking and feeling. This is the ideal anyway.
Cognitive dissonance challenges our beliefs, our brains seriously questions the way it thinks. Amazing, isn't that? We have the capacity of metacognition: the ability to think about our own systems of thought in order to consciously evolve them toward truth.
The resolution is more complex and difficult than our original state, but we are so much wiser for the process.
That is why I love your conclusion with the challenging Shakespeare quote: "The moment you stop thought, Time too stops dead." Thought patterns evolve and adapt, and if you stop with your metacognition, time starts. You are dead, at least in the mental sense.
The concept of neuroplasticity http://www.zipminis.com/brain-blog/supercharge-your-brain-even-after-trauma illustrates this. Neuroscience has discovered that your brain changes throughout your life, even into old age. This means you can improve your thinking, even in your declining years, if you actively devote your mind to it. The opposite is what Shakespeare describes in so few word - time stops.
Thank you Linda, for engaging my mind with your powerful writing.
Post a Comment